A 33-year-old woman was admitted to our department because of pain in right knee.
Her medical history was characterized by anorexia nervosa (AN) and personality disorder type AN binge purging. Her BMI was of 11.9 kg/m2.
Previously known substance and alcohol abuse in adolescence.
MRI of the knee showed severe changes in the intra-medullary fat with mildly low signal intensity in T1 weighted sequence and high signal intensity in STIR, which raised the suspicion of a technical problem.
For this reason, also a DP FS sequence was performed, confirming similar signal intensity and no fat signal suppression.
These findings are typical of the so-called “Flip-Flop effect”: it refers to a confusing MRI signal of the skeletal system that occurs in clinical conditions in which a severe fat depletion is present.
Similar findings were observed at the level of the subcutaneous tissues, with high signal intensity on all fat-suppressed fluid-sensitive sequences.
Coronal T1-weighted image showed some hypointense lines in the lateral tibial plateau, parallel to the joint surface, in keeping with insufficiency fractures.
The presence of a fair amount of joint effusion was also noted.
Serous atrophy of bone marrow, also known as gelatinous transformation of bone marrow, is a non-neoplastic disease that occurs with chronic illness and poor nutritional status with weight loss. Anorexia nervosa, malabsorption, chronic infections (e.g. AIDS, tuberculosis), malignant tumours, chronic heart failure, chronic kidney disease, alcoholism, cytotoxic drugs [1], acute febrile illness and myelodysplastic syndrome have been described as underlying conditions. Scientific literature has always shown a considerable interest in the connection between serous atrophy and anorexia nervosa [2].
From a clinical point of view, severe weight loss and anaemia are typical [3], however, a general decrease in hematopoiesis can lead to leukopenia, with increased risk of infection [4]. The major complication is the increased risk of fractures, due to the impairment of bone quality [5].
Serous atrophy of bone marrow is due to a massive fat mobilisation – in case of prolonged negative metabolic balance. A material made of hyaluronic acid-rich musopolysaccaride with jelly-like consistency fills the extracellular space in the cancellous bone. This criterion, together with a decrease in size and number of fat and hematopoietic components, is essential for the histopathological diagnosis, that takes place after the biopsy [3].
The term “Flip-Flop effect” derives from the inverse signal characteristics of medullary fat inside the bone. It is used in literature to characterise this disease.
The T1 weighted images seem to be fat-suppressed, with mildly low signal intensity of the bone marrow. The images sensitive to the suppressed fluid-inversion recovery as well as T2 with chemical fat suppression - appears to be non-fat-suppressed with high signal [6].
Fat depletion is also visible on MRI (decrease in volume of fat anywhere where there is fatty tissue), and lipodystrophy is characterized by decreased signal intensity on T1, increased on T2 and water-sensitive sequences and increased attenuation of the fat on CT.
These features can cause misdiagnosis: this type of signal could be mistaken for a technically defective MRI study.
The marrow does not enhance after paramagnetic contrast administration. This helps in the differential diagnosis with diffuse malignancy [7]. Chronic osteomyelitis may also be considered in the differential diagnosis for the impairment of bone quality, but the presence of cortical destructive changes, intramedullary abscess formation, cloaca formation, and, soft tissue inflammation, can help differentiate.
Take-home points
On MRI, the marrow has mildly signal intensity on T1 weighted sequences, while it has high signal intensity on images sensitive to the suppressed fluid – Flip-Flop effect.
Serous atrophy of bone marrow
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
The MRI of the patient’s right knee shows:
Overall, these characteristics suggest decreased fatty components of the bone marrow. Considering the patient’s clinical history, serious nutritional deficiency or physical depletion-related bone marrow changes should be highly suspected.
Considering the patient’s severe anorexia history (AN, with marked underweight and malnutrition) and the typical “Flip-Flop” appearance on imaging reflecting depletion of bone marrow fat, the most likely diagnosis is:
Serous Atrophy of Bone Marrow.
It is recommended to supplement with further laboratory tests (such as blood tests, bone density assessments, nutritional indicators) and consider bone marrow biopsy to rule out diffuse malignant bone marrow infiltration or other rare pathologies. If definitive clarification is required, histological diagnosis via biopsy is advised.
Based on the above diagnosis and the patient’s history, the main treatment and rehabilitation recommendations include:
Once nutritional status improves and body weight increases, a gradual rehabilitation and exercise routine should be implemented as follows:
Throughout rehabilitation, close attention should be paid to skeletal and joint status, as the patient’s bones are more fragile. Avoid sudden, high-impact, or high-intensity exercises. Ensure full warm-up before exercise and adequate stretching and relaxation afterward.
Disclaimer:
This report is based on the provided patient information and imaging data for analysis and is for reference only. It is not a substitute for in-person diagnosis and the guidance of professional physicians. If you have any questions or notice any changes in symptoms, please seek medical attention or consult a specialist promptly.
Serous atrophy of bone marrow