A 39-year-old man came to our department complaining of continuous pain of the right hand and wrist with inability to flex and extend it and swollen skin.
The patient suffered from an ulna-radius fracture 5 months before (Fig. 1) treated with surgery and immobilization (Fig.2).
After plaster removal, symptoms appeared; physiotherapy was not successful.
A hand and wrist X-ray (Fig. 3) showed results of ulna-radius fracture with bone callus formation, without any soft tissue specific findings except for a subtle lateral displacement of long axis between F1 over 5th MTC bone.
CT scan (Fig.4) showed:
- bone loss in the anatomical snuff box,
- irregular cortical bone due to severe chondropathy,
- scapho-lunate diastasis (Terry-Thomas sign) due to ligament lesion,
- posterior dislocation of the base of the fourth metacarpal bone with detachment of a bone fragment,
- posterior subluxation of the base of the fifth metacarpal bone,
- osteoporosis of carpal, metacarpal bones and distal part of radius and ulna, due to presence of algodystrophy.
3D volume rendering (Fig. 5) images helped to highlight CT findings and to plan surgical treatment.
Carpometacarpal joints(CMJ) are extremely stable because of their arthrodial morphology, the supporting ligaments (dorsal-metacarpal, palmar-metacarpal, and the two sets of interosseous ligaments), tendinous insertions and carpal bone alignment [1]. Pure CM dislocation (CMD) is extremely rare, fracture-dislocations (especially I and V range) are more common, together accounting for less than 1% of traumatic injuries of wrist and hand [2].
CMD affects mostly men between 20 and 40 years of age. The most common cause is high energy trauma with flex-extension mechanism.
Physical examination shows swelling and deformity of anatomical shape, pain, functional impairment, shortening of the fingers, preternatural rotation and neurological complications if compressed the deep branch of the ulnar nerve.
CMD may be divided into:
- dorsal (85% of cases),
- volar,
- lateral,
- divergent.
Imaging findings are essential to diagnose CMD: lateral, postero-anterior, oblique X-ray with prone hand at 30-45 degrees may reveal severe cases. On a lateral hand X-ray image the angle between the index and small metacarpal bone shaft and between the long and small metacarpal shaft may be used as screening to diagnose ulnar-sided CMD, when the angle is greater than 10° diagnosis and other imaging examination should be performed [3].
CT scan with 2D or 3D volume rendering is essential because X-ray underestimates the bone and joint injuries (fracture-dislocation), so CT is the preferred diagnostic imaging method for complete assessment of these injuries [4]. MRI shows ligament injuries.
CMD may lead to severe disability of the hand so treatment of choice should be early reduction and metacarpal resting [5].
CMD treatment is essentially surgical, both closed and open reduction may be administered.
Closed reduction, under fluoroscopic guidance, is usually successful in dislocations <10 days old, to ultimate stability percutaneous Kirschner wires or pinning may be necessary [6]. When the injury is older than three weeks or CMD is associated with major fractures open reduction (OR) is recommended.
OR starts with a longitudinal dorsal incision over the dislocated CMJ. After the lateralization of extensor carpal ulnaris, CMJ is well appreciable and any osteochondral debris may be removed. If fractures are present they need to be fixated. CMJ is then anatomically reduced and treated with Kirschner wires that could be removed after six weeks. In case of severe intra-articular comminution, an arthrodesis may be considered, with risk of future impairment and osteoarthritis [7].
During follow-up, X-ray examinations (to assure the correct alignment of the CMJ, to avoid secondary dislocations, prevalent in the first two weeks after surgery) and early rehabilitation (to avoid future impairment) is recommended [8].
Ulnar IV carpometacarpal dislocation, due to car accident
Based on the provided X-ray and CT images, a postoperative internal fixation of the right forearm radius and ulna fracture is observed. The fracture ends have been stabilized with internal fixation (including nails or pin-like implants), and the fracture alignment appears generally acceptable.
However, in the wrist area and the adjacent region between the bases of the 2nd to 5th metacarpals and the corresponding carpal bones, there is visible articular surface displacement, indicating abnormal alignment between the distal metacarpals and the corresponding carpal bones. On lateral and some coronal CT reconstruction images, noticeable displacement of the metacarpal bases can be seen, along with local soft tissue swelling, irregular joint spacing, and discontinuous articular surfaces, suggesting a dislocation or subluxation of the carpometacarpal joints (CMJ).
Additionally, there is swelling of muscles and soft tissues, with increased density around the joint, which may be related to persistent inflammatory responses or soft tissue injury. No clearly new and significant fracture lines are identified, but minor bony irregularities and small bone fragments may be present, requiring careful comparison of different sequence images. MRI (if available) could further indicate ligament injuries, but based on CT and X-ray findings, a CMJ dislocation and associated ligament damage are highly suspected.
Considering the patient is a 39-year-old male with a history of radius and ulna fracture surgery 5 months ago, who now presents with persistent pain, limited function, and local swelling, and given the significant misalignment of the wrist and carpometacarpal joint surfaces observed on multi-plane imaging (X-ray and CT), the most likely final diagnosis is:
Right Wrist Carpometacarpal (CMJ) Dislocation (Predominantly Dorsal)
Since it was identified 5 months post-injury, this is considered a relatively late diagnosis, potentially classified as a chronic dislocation.
Rehabilitation should follow a gradual, individualized plan. Stabilization of bones and joints is prioritized, followed by progressive restoration of joint flexibility and muscle strength to prevent muscle atrophy and joint contracture:
This report is a reference analysis based on available imaging and clinical information and does not replace an in-person examination or professional medical advice. Specific treatment plans should be tailored to the patient’s condition and carried out under the supervision of qualified medical professionals.
Ulnar IV carpometacarpal dislocation, due to car accident