This patient presented subacutely with left thigh pain for two months, and had an outpatient plain pelvic radiograph (Fig. 1).
She later presented acutely to the hospital after a short interval of having "heard a loud crack" in the left leg, then fallen, with no preceding trauma. At this point repeat radiography was performed (Fig. 2).
The outpatient radiograph was initially assessed as normal. Although indeed not demonstrating any femoral or pelvic fracture, it did in fact show focal cortical thickening of the left lateral proximal femur (Fig. 1).
At this site, one week later, a complete transverse fracture of the proximal femur was seen with some displacement (Fig. 2), with features consistent with atypical femoral fracture.
Fig. 3 shows the American Society of Bone and Mineral Research criteria for this classification of fracture.
A. Background
The concept of atypical femoral fracture in those receiving bisphosphonate therapy is well-known.
Focal cortical reaction at the fracture site may represent an early stage of disease that is radiologically detectable and hence present the opportunity for prompt treatment. In a cohort of 33 morphologically similar fractures, a majority had prior bisphosphonate therapy and around half demonstrated a lateral cortical thickening reaction on pre-fracture imaging [1].
B. Clinical Perspective
Bisphosphonates remain clinically useful in the treatment of osteoporosis and other conditions reducing bone density, and although the overall total rate of fracture is markedly reduced with their use [2], there is a concurrent increased risk of the atypical-type fracture described here [3]. Judicious use of imaging and a high index of suspicion are warranted when these patients present with thigh pain [1].
This particular patient was prescribed bisphosphonates (alendronic acid 70mg PO weekly) for over 10 years, to reduce fracture risk from long-term oral corticosteroid therapy for a connective tissue disorder. Alertness to fracture risk in this context may have allowed for early diagnosis/prophylactic fixation.
C. Imaging Perspective
The diagnosis of bisphosphonate-associated atypical fracture is made when a patient with a history of bisphosphonate use presents with a transverse fracture at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction, in the subtrochanteric region of the femur. This occurs commonly in post-menopausal women, but has also been reported in men [11, 13].
The preceding lateral cortical stress reaction has an uncertain pathophysiological correlate but probably represents chronic microfractures in the context of oversuppressed bone remodelling [4, 5].
Similar appearances may be seen on CT, and there are also diagnostic features on radionuclide imaging [6] and MRI [7].
D. Outcome
Patients with bisphosphonate-associated atypical femoral fractures are treated per the standard for subtrochanteric fractures in general; that is internal fixation, usually intramedullary nail [8]. Operative intervention improves outcomes [9], but does not always prevent progression [10] and there is a higher failure and revision rate compared to typical fractures [11], presumably due to the underlying disordered bone metabolism.
E. Take Home Message, Teaching Points
Clinicians should be aware of the association between bisphosphonate use and atypical femoral fracture, and suspect this pathology in patients who report insidious groin or hip pain. Mean duration of preceding bisphosphonate therapy is circa 5-9 years [9, 12].
Radiologists should be alert to the possibility of detecting a pre-fracture lesion, usually a cortical reaction of the lateral cortex, before progression to full fracture.
Written informed patient consent for publication has been obtained.
Bisphosphonate-associated atypical femoral fracture with preceding cortical reaction
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Based on the provided anteroposterior X-ray images of the pelvis (Fig. 1 taken at the initial visit; Fig. 2 taken at the follow-up visit), a transverse or near-transverse fracture line can be observed in the left subtrochanteric region (proximal portion of the femoral shaft). Especially in the second image, a clear interruption of lateral cortical continuity is noted, along with localized cortical thickening, indicative of stress reaction or instability. There is relatively minimal soft tissue swelling, but given the patient’s reported pain location and clinical background, a potential stress or atypical fracture should be strongly considered. No significant abnormal deformities or lesions are seen in the right femur or pelvis.
Taking into account the patient’s age (62 years), extensive bisphosphonate use history (over 10 years), mechanism of injury (no obvious trauma yet an audible “crack” before the fall), and radiological findings (transverse fracture line in the proximal femoral shaft with lateral cortical thickening), the most probable diagnosis is:
Left Proximal Femoral Atypical Fracture (Associated with Long-Term Bisphosphonate Use).
If doubts remain, MRI or bone scintigraphy can be employed to assess the extent of the stress reaction and bone metabolism, thereby ruling out pathological tumors or other abnormal findings if necessary.
In this case, rehabilitation should focus on restoring lower limb function post-surgery and progressively improving bone health, adhering to the FITT-VP principle (Frequency, Intensity, Time, Type, Progression, Individualization, Periodization). The following are recommended:
Throughout rehabilitation, closely observe localized pain, surgical incision healing, and fracture healing progress. If pain worsens, swelling appears, or mobility is restricted, seek medical evaluation promptly.
Disclaimer:
This report is formulated based on the provided medical and imaging data, with the intention of offering reference advice for clinical diagnosis and treatment. Actual treatment requires in-person consultation, further examinations, and a comprehensive evaluation by professional orthopedic and rehabilitation specialists. This report does not replace the formal medical diagnoses or treatment recommendations provided by qualified healthcare institutions.
Bisphosphonate-associated atypical femoral fracture with preceding cortical reaction
