A 37-year-old man came to our urgency department with shoulder pain following a fall on the point of the shoulder. Radiographs demonstrated widening of the acromioclavicular joint and an increased coracoclavicular distance.
A 37-year-old man, who was playing football, had a fall on the point of the shoulder. After that he complained of severe pain and limited mobility of the shoulder girdle. Clinical examination demonstrated the classic «piano key sign» (visible step-off where the clavicle can be pushed down but will spring back when pressure is released). He made radiographs (anteroposterior projection of shoulder and lateral projection of scapula) that showed widening of the acromioclavicular joint (1cm) and increased coracoclavicular distance (2cm). The diagnosis of grade III acromioclavicular separation was made (acromioclavicular dislocation).
Acromioclavicular separation is usually the result of a fall on the outstretched arm or point of the shoulder (1). Radiographs of a normal acromioclavicular (AC) joint show the inferior margins of the acromion and clavicle forming a continuous line or arc across the joint. Traumatic injury disrupts the relatively weaker AC ligament before the relatively stronger coracoclavicular ligaments, resulting in a predictable pattern of injury that is described by a three-stage grading system (Tossi grades). A grade 1 AC injury is an AC joint sprain without gross disruption of the AC joint. Radiographs may be normal or may show mild AC joint laxity with minimal subluxation. A grade 2 AC injury consists of complete disruption of the AC ligaments with intact coracoclavicular ligaments. Radiographs reveal widening of the AC joint, but a normal coracoclavicular distance. A grade 3 AC injury consists of complete disruption of both the AC and coracoclavicular ligaments (2). Passive inferior traction on the arm may reveal or help upgrade an AC injury that is not apparent without traction (3). Useful rules of thumb are that the AC joint space is usually no more than 5 mm wide and coracoclavicular distance is usually no wider than 11 to 13 mm. Although these numbers are worth remembering as useful guidelines, other factors such as clinical findings and a 50% difference between the two sides are also important (2). These injuries are treated conservatively in cases of grade I or II acromioclavicular joint separation, and surgically in many cases of grade Ill acromioclavicular joint separation. However, surgical connection of a grade Ill acromioclavicular joint separation is controversial, and many surgeons prefer closed treatment methods (3). Finally, the AC joint may appear widened by erosion of the distal clavicle because of rheumatoid arthritis, hiperparathyroidism, infection and traumatic osteolysis but clinical correlation usually leads to the correct diagnosis.
Grade III acromioclavicular joint separation.
The patient is a 37-year-old male who presented due to a shoulder collision injury. The X-ray images reveal:
Overall, these imaging findings are consistent with AC joint separation, showing marked structural disruption and abnormal alignment in the coracoclavicular ligament region.
Based on the clinical history and imaging findings, the possible diagnoses or differential diagnoses include:
Considering the mechanism of injury (fall or collision to the shoulder), the radiographic findings (marked widening of both AC joint and CC distance), and the clinical symptoms, the most likely diagnosis is:
Grade III AC joint separation (Tossi III AC joint injury).
If further confirmation is needed, additional physical examination, contralateral comparison X-rays, or MRI can be utilized to confirm complete ligament tears.
Treatment for Grade III AC joint separation remains somewhat controversial. Typically, the treatment options include:
Rehabilitation and Exercise Prescription Recommendations:
Throughout the rehabilitation process, if the patient has fragile bone health or additional comorbidities, it is crucial to thoroughly assess cardiopulmonary function and joint safety. If necessary, reduce training intensity and increase protective measures.
Disclaimer: This report is based solely on the provided clinical history and imaging information for reference purposes and does not replace an in-person consultation or professional medical advice. Specific diagnosis and treatment should be determined by a licensed medical institution or physician in conjunction with clinical examination, laboratory tests, and other relevant assessments.
Grade III acromioclavicular joint separation.