A 12-year-old girl presents with pain and swelling around the lateral side of her left knee. She underwent a MRI scan following a normal X ray of her knee.
A 12-year-old girl presents with a 2 year history of swelling and intermittent pain around the lateral aspect of her left knee. The pain was exacerbated with physical activity. There was no history of trauma locking or giving way. Examination showed a 2x2cm swelling with minimal tenderness around the head of her fibula. The overlying skin was normal and there was no effusion around the knee joint. She had full range of movement and the joint was stable. Anterior-posterior and lateral views of her knee were unremarkable.
The MRI of her knee was performed using the following protocol:
Sagittal T1W TSE, T2W FFE, PD SPAIR.
Coronal T1W TSE, T2W FFE, PD SPAIR, T1W TSE SPIR, T1W TSE SPIR + GADOLINIUM.
There is a cleft of abnormal signal within the lateral meniscus extending beyond the lateral margin, measuring 2x3x2 cm. This extends into the adjacent soft tissues as shown in figures 1-4. The signal characteristics are consistent with a tear within the lateral meniscus and a cystic fluid collection laterally, suggestive of myxoid degeneration.
Meniscal injury due to overuse results in myxoid degeneration with formation of a hollow space filled with mucopolysaccharide. This leads to an appearance of a cyst. The connective tissue will undergo an abnormal reaction following local mechanical stress. This defect tends to weaken the structure of the fibrocartilage tissue, precipitating a tear in the meniscus. The material within the cyst is either secreted by the meniscus cells or will be derived from the synovial fluid [1]. Cellular secretion is implicit in the theory of myxoid degeneration.
They are commonly identified with a MRI scan of the knee [2, 3], which also aids in defining the origin and size of these lesions [4]. Tyson et al reports that most of the meniscal cysts (91%) in his study of 62 MRI scans occurred immediately adjacent to the meniscal tear (98% of which were horizontal cleavage tears) with the tear leading directly into the cysts. It has been reported that meniscal cysts of the knee are a complication of meniscal tears that extend to the capsule and are three times more common on the lateral than the medial side [5, 6]. They are also most commonly found in men aged between 20 and 40 years [6]. Conventional spin-echo T1 weighted, proton density-weighted or gradient-echo sequences are necessary for identifying tears in the meniscus with cystic lesions. [7]. Myxoid degeneration is rarely found in children. It has been reported that a meniscal tear associated with degenerative changes might be regarded as the first sign of osteoarthritis of the joint. [8]. The presence of a tear is an important feature for the orthopaedic surgeon as it may influence their surgical approach [9]. If the patient was asymptomatic treatment would be conservative. In symptomatic cases, arthroscopic repair would be reccomended.
Myxoid degeneration of lateral meniscal cyst
Based on the provided knee MRI images, the following key features are observed:
Considering the patient's age (12 years), symptoms (lateral knee pain and swelling), and MRI findings, the following diagnoses can be considered:
Taking into account the patient's clinical presentation (lateral knee pain and swelling), MRI findings (horizontal or near-horizontal tear in the lateral meniscus with cystic changes), and the relative rarity but possibility of such injuries in this age group, the most likely final diagnosis is:
Lateral meniscal cyst with horizontal tear (with mucoid degeneration).
Should further confirmation be necessary, an arthroscopic examination could be considered to directly visualize the meniscal tear and rule out other soft tissue lesions.
The following are recommendations for treatment and rehabilitation:
If symptoms are mild or intermittent, short-term conservative management can be adopted, including reduction of intense activity, use of a knee brace, local physical therapy, and appropriate anti-inflammatory and pain relief medication (e.g., NSAIDs). However, given the significant pain and lateral knee swelling, close monitoring of symptoms is needed.
In cases of persistent pain, restricted activity, or a significantly sized cyst impacting joint function, arthroscopic meniscal repair or partial meniscectomy is recommended. During surgery, the cyst can also be addressed to prevent recurrence.
Rehabilitation should follow the FITT-VP principles (Frequency, Intensity, Time, Type, Progression) and be tailored to the patient’s individual condition in a stepwise fashion:
Special reminder: As meniscal injuries can worsen with twisting, over-extension, and high-load activities, training techniques must be carefully monitored. Avoid sudden, high-intensity lower limb movements to prevent re-injury.
This report is a reference analysis based on current medical imaging and medical history data. It is not a substitute for an in-person consultation or professional medical advice. Specific treatment plans should be determined based on the patient’s actual clinical condition under the guidance of a specialist.
Myxoid degeneration of lateral meniscal cyst