Cleft injury in a young football player: A case of athletic pubalgia

Clinical Cases 19.03.2024
Scan Image
Section: Musculoskeletal system
Case Type: Clinical Cases
Patient: 25 years, male
Authors: Stefano Lusi 1, Giorgia Carnicelli 1, Gian Marco Frigerio 1, Marco Francone 2, Nicola Magarelli 2
icon
Details
icon
AI Report

Clinical History

A 25-year-old male professional football player sought medical attention for the onset of severe groin pain the day after an important match, more intense on the right side. He denied having had any direct trauma or previous illness. Ultrasound (US) examination performed by the sports medicine doctor was reported negative. A Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the pelvis was prescribed for the patient, referring to persistent pain.

Imaging Findings

On the coronal T2-weighted image, a linear hyperintensity is seen at the level of the pubic joint disc along the intra-articular space, representing the “physiologic cleft (normal configuration) (Figures 1 and 2).

Linear hyperintensity on T2-weighted sequence can be appreciated along the right inferior (“secondary cleft sign”) margin of the right pubic ramus, representing tearing of the short adductor (gracilis, adductor brevis, pectineus) aponeurosis (Figures 1 and 2).

The exam also documents osteo-cartilaginous changes at the level of the pubic symphysis, mostly evident on the right side, due to repeated stress and microtraumas.

Discussion

Groin injuries are among the most common and time-consuming injuries in football, accounting for 419% of all injuries, with an incidence of 0.22.1 injuries per 1000 hours of play in males [1].

While athletic pubalgia is the official medical term, the more commonly used name among patients is still “sports hernia”, also known as Gilmores hernia or Sportsmans hernia. This term actually refers not to a hernia at all, since there is often no visible bulge, but rather a strain or tear in the soft tissue of the groin region, especially the aponeurosis or tendon insertions [2].

The Doha agreement meeting on terminology in groin pain in athletes aimed to clarify and categorise all possible causes of the pathology [3]. The consensus identified three major categories using a clinically-based taxonomy: A) defined clinical entities (adductor-related, iliopsoas-related, inguinal-related and pubic-related groin pain); B) hip-related groin pain; C) other musculoskeletal causes.

Groin injuries are historically considered challenging to diagnose and treat due to complex anatomy and subtle symptoms [4].

Ultrasound can be useful to rule out non-musculoskeletal causes (abdominal, gynaecological and urological conditions), and as a first screening. It can, in fact, be very useful in finding the site of the lesion, but good skill and experience are often required. Four areas should be investigated to check the four main sites of groin pain: the adductor point, iliopsoas, inguinal and pubic point.

If we cannot find the cause, but the patient still has pain, then an MRI is often required. A “secondary cleft sign” (involvement of the short adductor) or a “superior cleft sign” (involvement of the adductor longus or rectus-adductor aponeurosis) are very well demonstrated on T2-sequences and considered pathognomonic, unequivocally clarifying the cause of pain. Lesions most often involve only one aspect of the pubic ramus, but can exceptionally occur in both the two, as in the case of a combined cleft sign.

In some settings, a contrast injection symphysography is still performed. This shows a contrast leakage along the inferior or superior margin of the pubis ramus, or both, exactly as in MR imaging, but with a more invasive procedure and with potential side effects.

Therapeutic options may vary based on the level of sport practised. In the vast majority of cases, groin injuries are managed non-surgically with rest, lidocaine and physiotherapy. In some situations, surgical management may be required, especially in professional settings [5].

All patient data have been completely anonymised throughout the entire manuscript and related files.

Differential Diagnosis List

Pelvic insufficiency fracture
Inguinal or femoral hernia
Athletic pubalgia
Nerve entrapment (obturator, ilioinguinal, genitofemoral, iliohypogastric)

Final Diagnosis

Athletic pubalgia

Figures

icon
Coronal T2-weighted fat-suppressed imaging (Dixon sequence) showing the superior cleft sign on the right side of the pubic joint.

icon
Coronal T2-weighted Dixon sequence: focus on the pubic joint. The image depicts the secondary cleft (blue arrow) and the tear of the short adductors, which are minimally retracted, with a small gap filled with fluid (red arrow).