12-year-old boy who fell on his knee.
Companion Case: 21 F with limited knee extension 5 months after accident.
(Fig. 1-2) Coronal and sagittal MR images of the knee showing a recent, minimally displaced anterior tibial spine fracture fragment attached to an intact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL).
(Fig. 3-6) Companion case of a 21-year-old female patient with plain radiographs and MR images demonstrating a remote nonunited tibial fragment attached to an intact anterior cruciate ligament.
The anterior cruciate ligament attaches proximally to the posterior medial surface of the lateral femoral condyle and distally to the anterior intercondylar area in the tibia. Its tibial insertion is broad and fanlike and is located slightly lateral and anterior to the anterior tibial spine [1]. Although tearing of the anterior cruciate ligament most commonly occurs at its midsubstance, an avulsion fracture of the ligament from its tibial insertion occurs in a minority of cases and is more common in children than in adults, particularly those between eight to thirteen years of age [1-2]. These injuries are more common in the skeletally immature population due to the relative increased strength of the ligament compared with the developing bone and growth plate [3]. In children, this injury occurs secondary to hyperflexion of the joint and internal tibial rotation and is uncommonly accompanied by other ligamentous injuries [1-2].
On conventional radiographs, these avulsion fractures may be difficult to recognize, although the presence of a small bone fragment in the region of the intercondylar notch with cortical irregularity of the adjacent tibial eminence suggestive of a donor site may be the usual findings. MR imaging is useful for confirmation of the tibial site of the fragment, evaluation of the rest of the ligament and assessment for additional injuries [2].
It is crucial for the radiologist to accurately identify this injury. Failure or delay in diagnosis may eventually result in nonunion and persistent clinical symptoms such as limitation or pain on knee extension and anterior instability [4]. In addition, classification of ACL avulsion fractures may dictate the management. The Meyers and McKeever classification system describes four subtypes of tibial spine fractures: presence of a minimally displaced fragment (type I), anterior elevation of the fragment (type II) complete separation of the fragment from the tibia (types III and IV) with rotational component or comminution (type IV). Type I injuries are managed conservatively, while arthroscopy is recommended for type II– IV lesions with types III and IV injuries requiring internal fixation [5].
In conclusion, it is imperative for the radiologist to recognize and correctly diagnose an ACL avulsion fracture to facilitate early and appropriate management and prevent future anterior knee instability.
Anterior cruciate ligament avulsion fracture
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Based on the patient’s age of 12 years, history of trauma from a fall, and imaging findings, the most likely diagnosis is “ACL Avulsion Fracture at the Tibial Attachment.” This injury is relatively common in children and is associated with hyperflexion and internal rotation stress.
According to the Meyers and McKeever classification, if the fracture fragment displacement is minor (Type I or II), conservative treatment may be considered; if the displacement is significant (Type III or IV), arthroscopic surgery or internal fixation is required to stabilize the fragment and protect ligament function.
The following rehabilitation training program should be carried out under the guidance of a specialist or physical therapist, and adjusted flexibly according to the patient’s individual recovery status:
If bone fragility or other medical conditions (e.g., poor cardiopulmonary function) are present, further reduction of training volume or shorter sessions may be needed, and close monitoring of the patient’s condition is necessary.
Disclaimer: This report is based on available imaging and medical history for reference purposes and does not replace face-to-face consultation or professional medical advice. If you have any questions or if symptoms worsen, please contact a specialist doctor or return to the hospital for follow-up treatment.
Anterior cruciate ligament avulsion fracture